The nail that sticks out gets hammered downthat

I just watched a film called “But I didn’t do it!” (それでもやってない),in which a  young man is falsely accused of groping a teenage girl on a packed subway train.  The protagonist’s private rage and frustration are contrasted with the slow-turning and at times corrupt wheels of Japanese justice.  Held in custody during a seven month investigation and  trial period,  he is  repeatedly advised that Japan has a 99.9% conviction rate and that  it is thus futile to fight rather than to plea bargain.

As I watched I knew there wouldn’t be an American “bucks the system” happy end.  The inevitable verdict of “guilty”  is a thudding admonishment to bow to authority as much as it is a punishment for said crime.

In America, it’s the corporation that is portrayed with such arrogance and corruption— remember Silkwood, China  Syndrome, Erin Brokovich—while our legal system is still  a venue for redemption.  I don’t yet know where Japanese find salvation in such moments.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.